Are prong collars cruel? Well, there are plenty of collars out there that are designed to train your dog, one of them is prong collars. However, some people see that this kind of collars are cruel and should not be used in training dogs. But, we see that we need to learn more about prong collars, today, before making any decisions.
Prong collars and choke collars are both training tools that are used to punish your dog for pulling, and to teach him/her to obey your rules and not pull when you order him/her to stay. So, yes prong collars can be cruel if used
Today we are going to talk about the Prong Collars because we already talked about the Choke Collars before in this article Are Choke Collars Cruel? so, please feel free to check it out if you have any questions about Choke Collars.
Table of Contents
Are Prong Collars Cruel?
Well, to answer this question, we need to know the good and the bad in the prong collar and learn why and how dog owners prefer using them, and it is still extremely popular despite its bad reputation.
The good in the prong collars:
- Prong collars can be a lifesaver
- Prong collars are a very effective communicating tool
- Prong collars are a very good training tool
Prong collars can be a lifesaver.
A lot of dog owners own huge dogs that are known for their aggressive reactions like these dogs that are, according to Forbes, known as the most dangerous dogs. To be honest, we can’t blame a dog owner for owning the dog he/she felt connected to, however, the dog owner can’t risk his/her dog being aggressive with any person or animal in the street, and also he/she can lock the door indoors and not letting him/her out.
Therefore, the prong collars here becomes the perfect solution for everybody, he/she will be able to walk his/her dog as normal as any other dog owner, and the dog will be able to walk around and smell some fresh air without harming anyone around thanks to the prong collar, that helps the dog owner control his/her dog when needed.
Prong collars are a very effective communicating tool.
I know that once you look at the prong collar you get the feeling that it is kind of like a torture tool, not a collar that can help you communicate with your dog. But, for real, it is not. In fact, there are ways you can use prong collars in a way that is as humane as any other collar can be.
All the prong collars do is putting some pressure around your dog’s neck, and to be accurate, it is a totally acceptable level of pressure for a dog, as a way of communicating with your dog without having to yell at him/her in the middle of the street. It is just a way to tell him/her that he/she is pulling too hard and that he/she needs to stop pulling, right now.
By doing that, and by time, your dog will understand that you need him/her to slow down, and stop pulling; which means that by the time you will not need to use a prong collar again.
Prong collars are a very good training tool.
Let’s put in our mind why you bought your dog prong collars in the first place. You needed your dog to behave better while walking with you, and stop pulling you and hurt your arm every time he/she sees something or someone he/she wants to smell or play with, right? You wanted both of you to have peace and safe quality time together.
And that what prong collars will give you and your dog by time, and by using it the right way. Because, as we mentioned before, prong collars can be very cruel if used the wrong way, your dog will behave and will fully understand the lesson, so you “literally” have a very good training tool if you know how to use it.
And that will lead us to the next point.
The bad in the prong collars:
- Prong collars are not a 24/7 collar.
- Prong collars should be used by people who know how to use it.
- Prong collars need to be used by a very caring and responsible dog owner.
Prong collars is not a 24/7 collar.
Like any other thing in the world, if misunderstood or misused, it can be very harmful. Therefore, the first thing that you need to do when you decide to buy your dog prong collars is that it is not a regular collar that your dog can wear it all day.
Prong collars should only be used during the training time, and preferably for not a long time, too. Remember, the main reason is training your dog to behave better, not punishing him/her and grab him/her from the neck all day!
Which leads us to out next point:
Prong collars should be used by people who know how to use it.
If you brought prong collars to your dog just to grab him/her for the neck for every he/she does, you are not using it right, and you are being so cruel with your dog!
Therefore, you need to know how to use it before you bring your dog one, and you need to use it for only the reason it is made for, which is training.
Prong collars need to be used by a very caring and responsible dog owner.
Another very important and worth mentioning point is that you need, as a dog owner, to be very responsible while you are using prong collars, and you need to know that it makes your dog uncomfortable, that is why it should be used for only the purpose it is made for.
Also, you need to know that all of the horror stories we keep hearing about dogs that were found with neck injuries as a result of prong collars, was not because of the prong collars itself, but because of the irresponsible dog owner that misused prong collars.
Therefore, any dog owner who decided to use prong collars needs to be as responsible and caring as his/her dog expecting him/her to be.
Also check this video from a dog trainer, you will learn a lot!
Things you need to know before you get your dog prong collars.
Another important piece of information you need to be aware of is that you have to get your dog the perfect size for his/her neck, because it should not be so tight and, of course, not too loose, too.
Also, you need to know that a lot of dog owners are against prong collars, and they also believe that you are torturing your dog. So, you might get a lot of evil looks while you are walking your dogs. However, as long as you believe in whatever you are doing, just keep doing it.
Moreover, you need to make sure that you know all about prong collars before you decide that your dog needs one. Because, simply, some dogs just don’t need one. Therefore, you need to make sure you asked the write person, which is preferably a professional trainer or your dog’s veterinaria before you get your dog a prong collar.
Furthermore, you need to make sure that you get your dog the best quality, and for that, I recommend you check out our latest collars and get yourself the best offers from here:
And, of course, you can find anything your dog will ever need here, so check it now before it is too late!
Now you know what you need to know about prong collars, and it is your turn to make the decision.
Should I use a prong collar for my dog?
If you cannot take full control of your dog’s movement while walking him/her around your block, and he/she causes so much trouble to you by pulling your arm so hard that it hurts, or you have a very dangerous and aggressive dog that you know he/she can cause a serious harm to anyone or any other animal around; yes, you need to use a prong collar.
But, if you have a very kind, decent, well-behaved dog that cannot hurt a fly, and he/she can walk with you without making any trouble to you or anybody or animal around; no, just need the dog’s regular collar, you don’t need a prong collar for your dog.
Should I use a prong collar or a choke collar for my dog?
Well, it is your call. Both are used for the same reason, to help your dog understand that he/she needs to stop pulling. I believe that the only difference is that the prong collar contains metal spikes on the inside, but still, both of them serve the same cause.
However, you might need to ask your dog’s veterinarian and follow your heart, see what your dog will need in this stage and get it to him/her. You might think that a choke collar is enough and the prong collar is too much. It is your dog, so you get to choose what you think is better for him/her, as long as we are talking about two objects serving the same purpose.
Now, why don’t you share with us what do you prefer? And also, I would love to hear all the succes stories if you or someone you know tried prong collars for their dogs!